More Discussions for this daf
1. Rebbi Yishma'el's Accident 2. Melachah Sh'einah Tzericha l'Gufa, by a Zav's pouch 3. Asking for Forgiveness on Shabbos
4. Did Yosef Have to be Taught Lashon Arami by the Angel? 5. Gezeirah l'Gezeirah 6. Killing a Bug on Shabbos
7. Visiting the Sick 8. Going out with an object on Erev Shabbos 9. Covering one's head with the Talis
10. The angels and prayer 11. Girsa in Ba'meh Madlikin 12. Killing a louse on Shabbos
13. Praying for a sick person on Shabbos 14. Tefilin 15. Aramaic
DAF DISCUSSIONS - SHABBOS 12

Barry Weinberger asked:

1) When davening b'yechidus, why can we say the first yekum purkan on Shabbos if the malachim don't understand Aramaic?

2) Why can daven in Aramaic at all, even with a minyan?

Thank you.

Barry Weinberger, Cherry Hill, USA

The Kollel replies:

1) According to the Mishnah Berurah (101:19) a person davening b'yechidus should not say the first Yekum Purkan either.

2) The Mishnah Berurah (ibid:16) explains that the tefilos of the tzibur are dealt with directly by Hash-m. The tefilos of an individual are handled by malachim. Malachim do not understand Aramaic.

Yehuda Landy