RAV PAPA'S QUESTIONS ABOUT KEMITZAH AND CHAFINAH (cont'd)
Question: Would the K'li Shareis be Mekadesh if he stuck the Kometz to its inner walls (fulfilling Toch) or must it fall to the bottom (a proper Hanachah)?
Question (Mar b. R. Ashi): What if he turned over the K'li Shareis and stuck the Kometz into its base (a proper Hanachah but not Toch?
Question: Is the Chafinah a heaping or level hands-full?
Answer: The Beraisa teaches that it is in between.
Question (after citing the Halachos of collecting and spilling blood and their sources R. Papa asks): If the Ketores spilled on the floor from the M'lo Chafnav:
Do we say that his hand is like the neck of the animal (and the Ketores would be Pesulah like the blood which spilled from the animal's neck) or;
Are his hands like a K'li Shareis and the Ketores is not Pesulah.
Question: If he thought (as he did the Chafinah) to be Maktir the Ketores the next day, do we learn from "M'lo" to connect it to the Minchah or not?
Answer: We see from R. Akiva's addition to the Mishnah in Iduyos that since Linah creates a P'sul, so, too, does Machshavah.
Question: Is the Chatiyah of the coals an Avodah, such that a Machshavah could make it Pigul, or is a Machshir not considered like the Mitzvah itself?
R. SHEISHES AND HOLACHAH WITH THE LEFT HAND
Question (asked of R. Sheishes): What if the Holachah of the blood of a Korban is performed with the left hand?
Answer: We see from our Mishnah (where the Kaf is carried in his left hand) that carrying with the left is Kosher.
Question: Why didn't R. Sheishes learn directly from the Mishnah in Tamid where Holachah (of the Eivarim) is done with the left hand?
Answer: We might have differentiated since the Eivarim are not integral to the Kaparah as the Zerikah (and its associated Holachah) are.