More Discussions for this daf
1. Concern for Kishuf 2. The Me'iri 3. Why answer, if you have to say something that's not true?
4. Machlokes Tanaim
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BAVA METZIA 23

Ari Kellerman asks:

Why does the gemara assume that the tana kama argues on r' Yehuda's statement of davar sheyesh bo shinui in the mishnah? Could r'yehuda simply be adding an independent halacha? Why must we assume it's a machlokes at all?

Ari Kellerman, United States

.