More Discussions for this daf
1. Order of the Sotah testing process 2. Implication that Kefifa Mitzris is not fit to be Kli Shares 3. Erasing Megilas Sotah
4. Definition of a Saris 5. Mizbeach in the North of the Azarah 6. Moses Yeled, with Kol Na'ar.
7. מחיקת מגילת סוטה 8. הלכה עוקבת מקרא
DAF DISCUSSIONS - SOTAH 14

H David Levine asks:

To R' Nechemia, is it not clearly a, 'mum ovair,' since before time of avodah he will have grown?

H David Levine, Roanoke, VA USA

The Kollel replies:

Shalom R' Levine,

Great to hear from you.

This is a very good point! See the comment of the Mizrachi to Rashi on Shemos 2:6 who tries to deal with your question by saying that Rebbi Nechemiah believes that if Moshe Rabeinu's voice was different than his peers when he was a baby, then we can assume it that when he grows older also his voice will continue to be aberrant, albeit in a new way, which would in fact disqualify him for the Avodas ha'Shir of the Leviim.

Alternatively, see the comment of the Maharsha (Sotah 12b DH Kari Leih) who explains -- unlike Rashi on the Gemara -- that by "Baal Mum" Rebbi Nechemia meant simply irregular and thus deformed, but nothing to do with the Avodah.

I hope this helps to address your pereceptive question.

Warmest regards,

Yishai Rasowsky