More Discussions for this daf
1. Rebbi Yochanan's Kal v'Chomer 2. Rav Zutra question on Rav Nachman 3. "Mashi'ach"
4. Using the Kula 5. Rav'ani Le'onsi 6. Bottom Tosfos
7. Warning by a Shed or by one's self 8. Intent to be Edim 9. Witnesses and Warnings
10. A Person Seeing Something After He Dies?
 DAF DISCUSSIONS - MAKOS 6
1. harvey/mechael asked:

The excerpt below is from Makkos 6b.

What good is a warning by a Shed, when we cant bring a shed to court to testify that he gave the warning?

Also what good is a warning by one's self, when there is a law that one can't indict himself by his own words???

[Halachah Outlines, Makos 6]

(i) (Rava): The warning can be even by himself (Rashi - the victim warned him; Kesef Mishnah - the transgressor said 'I know that Beis Din will kill me for this') or by a Shed.

harvey/mechael, lost angeles

2. The Kollel replies:

The court does not have to see the one who gave the warning. It is enough if witnesses testify that a warning was given by an anonymous being (a "Shed") or that the sinner himself acknowledged that he was committing a sin.

This is not considered indicting himself. It is occurred as part of the crime, rather than as part of the testimony.

Mordecai Kornfeld

Kollel Iyun Hadaf