More Discussions for this daf
1. Shema Yekadmenu Acher b'Rachamim 2. Laundering flax on Chol ha'Mo'ed 3. Zivugim vs. Kibud Av
4. Getting engaged on Yom Tov 5. Shmuel: Bris Kerusah li'Sefasayim 6. Moustache
7. From Torah, Prophets and Writings, man's wife is from Hash-m. 8. אין כותבין שטרי חוב במועד
DAF DISCUSSIONS - MOED KATAN 18

Dovid Bleeman asked:

It seems from the gemara that only on chol hamoed is it permitted to be "meares" however on yom tov itself it is oser. The reshonim speak this out as well. My understanding is the only only reason it would be oser is because of Mecach umemchar. Why would this not be permitted because of "chefzai shomayim motarim" (shabbos 12(1)) "olishadech habonos")

Dovid Bleeman, jerusalem

The Kollel replies:

"Cheftzei Shamayim" is a Heter for the Isur of "v'Dabru Davar," which is an Isur of speaking Devarim Shel Chol on Shabbos, whereas the Isur of Kinyan is an enactment made because of the concern that perhaps one will come to write on Shabbos. Thus, the Heter of Cheftzei Shamayim is not applicable.

D. Zupnik