58b----------------------------------------58b

1)

RAISING ONE'S HAND TO STRIKE ANOTHER

וא"ר חנינא הסוטר לועו של ישראל כאילו סוטר לועו של שכינה שנאמר (משלי כ) מוקש אדם ילע קודש: מגביה עבדו שבת סימן: אמר ריש לקיש כל המגביה ידו על חברו אע״פ שלא הכהו נקרא רשע שנא׳ (שמות ב יג) ויאמר לרשע למה תכה רעך הכית לא נאמר אלא תכה אע״פ שלא הכהו נקרא רשע זעירי א״ר חנינא נקרא חוטא שנאמר (ש״א ב טז) ואם לא לקחתי בחזקה וכתיב (שם) ותהי חטאת הנערים גדולה מאד את פני ה׳ רב הונא אמר תקצץ ידו שנאמר (איוב לח טו) וזרוע רמה תשבר רב הונא קץ ידא ר׳ אלעזר אומר אין לו תקנה אלא קבורה שנאמר (שם כב ח) ואיש זרוע לו הארץ ואמר ר״א לא נתנה קרקע אלא לבעלי זרועות שנאמר ואיש זרוע לו הארץ. ואמר ר״ל מ״ד (משלי יב יא) עובד אדמתו ישבע לחם אם אדם עושה עצמו כעבד לאדמה ישבע לחם ואם לאו לא ישבע לחם:
Translation: And R. Chanina said: One who slaps the cheek of a Yisrael is considered as though he slapped the cheek of the Divine Presence, as it is stated (Mishlei 20:25): "It is a snare for a person to say rashly 'Holy'". (The Pasuk is expounded to mean: One who "strikes" ('Nokesh') a Jew is considered as though he struck the "cheek" (Lo'a) of the Holy One.) A sign (as a mnemonic for the next three statements): 'Magbiah; Avdo; Shabbos'. Reish Lakish said: Anyone who raises his hand against his fellow, even though he did not strike him, is called wicked, as it is stated (Shemos 2:13), "and he said to the wicked one, why would you strike your fellow?" It does not say "why did you strike," but "why would you strike," teaching that even if he did not strike him, he is called wicked. Ze'iri said that R. Chanina said: He is called a sinner, as it is written (Shmuel I 2:16) "and if you do not take by force," and it is written (Shmuel I 2:17), "and the sin of the youths was very great before the Lord." Rav Huna said: (If a person habitually raises his hand to strike others) his hand should be cut off, as it is stated (Iyov 38:15), "and the high arm shall be broken." Rav Huna cut off the hand (of such a person). R. Elazar says: He has no remedy except burial, as it is stated (Iyov 22:8), "and a man of arm, to him is the land". And R. Elazar said (another interpretation of that Pasuk): Land was given only to men of force, as it is stated "and a man of arm, to him is the land." Reish Lakish said: What is the meaning of that which is written (Mishlei 12:11), "one who works his land will be satisfied with bread"? If a person makes himself like a slave to the land, he will be satisfied with bread; if not, he will not be satisfied with bread.
(a)

Why does the Gemara condemn raising a hand so harshly if no physical damage occurred?

1.

Alei Shor (Vol. 1 p. 152): Raising a hand marks the critical boundary where internal emotion crosses into physical action. Even though he did not actually strike the person, the mere physical movement proves the Yetzer haRa (evil inclination) has already hijacked the body. He is branded a Rasha (wicked person) because his physical faculties are now controlled by impulse rather than reason.

2.

Imrei Kohen (Rav Meir Warszawiak Hy"d of Monkitov): Reish Lakish's condemnation applies when a person's refraining from hitting did not stem from a righteous decision. In the case of the Pasuk, the individual was a Rasha (wicked person) who would routinely carry out his evil thoughts. He only refrained on this specific occasion because of Moshe's rebuke and his fear of Moshe. However, if a person voluntarily backs down out of their own self-restraint and does not ultimately strike someone, they do not fit into this severe category and are not labeled a Rasha.

(b)

Is Rav Huna's punishment to be taken literally?

1.

Yad Ramah: Yes, he literally had the man's hand cut off.

2.

Rabbeinu Chananel: He gave him a monetary punishment.

(c)

Why is the punishment of burial suitable for the crime of raising a hand against his fellow?

1.

Ben Yehoyada: The head is the highest spiritual level (the seat of the intellect and Neshama), while the hands are a lower level meant for action. By raising a hand over a head to strike, a person reverses the order, making the lower elements superior to the higher. His measure-for-measure remedy is burial, as man normally stands on top the dust, but in burial, the dust, the lowest element, is placed permanently on top of him.

(d)

What is behind the Gemara's statement that the land was given to 'Baalei Zero'os' - 'men of force'?

1.

Rashi: Land ownership is only suitable for tough people, as it can involve warding away animals who will damage it and standing up against thieves who try to steal from it or make fraudulent claims about its ownership.

2.

Maharsha: It refers to people who are physically strong, as cultivating land involves much difficult manual labor.

3.

Ben Yehoyada: The earth is spiritually built from Gevurah (strength/might), a Divine trait also called "the arm." This is why Kayin, according to Bereishis Rabbah 22:7, whose soul came from Gevurah, took the land as his share of the world, while Hevel took the movable items. Therefore, "men of force" does not just mean tough people. It refers to people who come from the spiritual root of Kayin, which makes them naturally driven to own and control the physical earth.

2)

A NON-JEW WHO OBSERVES SHABBOS

ואר"ל עובד כוכבים ששבת חייב מיתה שנא' (בראשית ח) ויום ולילה לא ישבותו ואמר מר אזהרה שלהן זו היא מיתתן אמר רבינא אפילו שני בשבת
Translation: Reish Lakish said: A non-Jew who observes Shabbos is liable for the death penalty, as it is stated: "And day and night shall not cease" (Bereishis 8:22). And the Master said: Their warning is their death penalty. Ravina said: Even (if they observed a day of rest) on a Monday.
(a)

Why did Ravina mention Monday rather than Sunday? (Maharsha)

1.

Rashi: By mentioning Monday, it is clear that the prohibition to rest is not specifically when the gentile is doing it as a religious Sabbath, such as on Saturday or Sunday. The prohibition is to refrain from work on any day of the week.

2.

Chasam Sofer (Bereishis 1:31 - quoting the Hafla'ah): It would have been less novel to apply it to Sunday, since on Sunday, elsewhere in the world it is still Shabbos (due to the different time zones) and it would be more obvious that the non-Jew would be liable. Monday is the first day of the week when it is no longer Shabbos anywhere in the world.

3.

HaBoneh on Ein Yaakov to Avoda Zara 40b: The gentiles have a role as "watchmen" to keep the world in working order and maintain continuous productivity. While Sunday was already a religious day of rest for others, Monday was a completely standard workday. By mentioning Monday, Ravina teaches that a gentile is liable for halting productivity on an ordinary day of labor, even without any religious motive.