Nazir Chart #5
Chart for Nazir Daf 20a-b
"KLAL" = One witness says, "He accepted 2 sets of Nezirus."
The other says, "He accepted 5 sets of Nezirus."
"MONEH" = One witness says, "He accepted 1 Nezirus, then a 2nd."
The other says, "He accepted 3 sets, then a 4th and a 5th."
WHEN ONE WITNESS TESTIFIES THAT A PERSON ACCEPTED 2 SETS OF NEZIRUS, AND A SECOND WITNESS TESTIFIES THAT HE ACCEPTED FIVE, DO THEY JOIN TO OBLIGATE HIM IN 2 SETS?
| (A) BEIS HILLEL |
(B) BEIS SHAMAI |
||
| RAV (IN BAVLI & YERUSHALMI) | |||
| 1a | "KLAL" | They join | They conflict |
| 1b | "MONEH" | They conflict (1) | They conflict |
| MA'ARAVA (BAVLI) | |||
| 2a | "KLAL" | They join | They conflict(2) |
| 2b | "MONEH" | They join | They join |
| REBBI YOCHANAN (YERUSHALMI) | |||
| 3a | "KLAL" | They join | They join |
| 3b | "MONEH" | They join | They conflict (1) |
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) According to Rav, and according to Rebbi Yochanan in the Yerushalmi, "Moneh" is considered to be a more contradictory testimony than "Klal" (see Insights). (2) It seems from the wording of Ma'arava that "Klal" is considered to be a more contradictory testimony than "Moneh." In the case of "Moneh," even Beis Shamai agrees that the witnesses join.