More Discussions for this daf
1. v'Nashal or v'Nishal? 2. Galus 3. Euthanasia
4. Hillel and Shammai 5. Abaye's question 6. Next of Kin for Go'el ha'Dam
7. Derech Yeridah 8. Shogeg 9. Yesh Eim la'Mikra
10. bi'Shegagah Prat l'Meizid 11. Killer courts 12. Edim Zomemim Unaware of Consequences of Their Edus
13. Disqualifying Eidim of Treifah 14. Once in 7, once in 70... 15. Tereifah by human beings
16. Mezid 17. Who does not go to the Ir Miklat 18. pelach
19. Machlokes of R'Yochanan and R'Abahu 20. Machlokes Rebbi Avahu & Rav Yochanan 21. "Tree" in the Pasuk
22. Cities of refuge - Roller on roof
 DAF DISCUSSIONS - MAKOS 7
1. hgschild asked:

Does anyone/which perush relate this capital punishment machlokes to the general machlokes between Beis Hillel (Shimon ben Gamliel) and Beis Shammai (Tarfon and Akiva)

hgschild, new hempstead usa

2. The Kollel replies:

I'd be quite surprised if they did. After all, those who analyze the classic Beis Hill/Shamai argument (such as R' Reuven Margaliyos in many of his Sefarim) tend to say that Beis Hillel had more flexibile halachic parameters than Beis Shamai (of course, within halachah). Being that Rebbi Tarfon and Rebbi Akiva are being lenient, it doesn't seem to fit the typical pattern. [By the way, I am quite impressed with your knowledge that Rebbi Akiva was somewhat rooted in Beis Shamai (see Toras Chaim in Bava Basra 158b).]

All the best,

Yaakov Montrose