More Discussions for this daf
1. Mehalech k'Omed 2. Ben Azai 3. Tosfos DH b'Kosel Meshupa
4. Ramban and Meleches Machsheves 5. The hand of a person is considered 4 by 4 6. water on water
7. Akirah and Hanachah 8. Akirah from 4 x 4 9. Reshus Ha'Yachid Mekureh
10. Akirah on Water 11. ò÷éøä åäðçä 12. øùØé ãØä ãøê ñèéå åøùØé ãó æ' ãØä áéï äòîåãéí
 DAF DISCUSSIONS - SHABBOS 5
1. David Hirsch asks:

What is poshat in Tosfos?

"Omer Ri d'Ayri Kgon she'Rabim Mekasfim Alav d'Havi Reshus ha'Rabim."

How is one Mekasef on a slanted wall?

Dovid Hirsch, Yerushalayim

2. The Kollel replies:

Shalom R' David,

It's great to hear from you!

I certainly understand the logic of your question. If a wall is slanted, it would seem to be an unstable surface; after all, the Gemara notes that water would slide right off it. How, then, could it serve as a functional place for people to rest their heavy burdens?

To me, the most straightforward explanation is that we are dealing with a gentle slope rather than a steep one. Just as the Gemara explains that the slope is moderate enough that a Sefer would stay put without falling off, the same applies to the pedestrians in the public thoroughfare who need the wall for support; because the incline is gradual, it is convenient to lean against it or rest their packs upon it momentarily to re-adjust their load as they travel.

The point is that since it is functional and frequently used by the public for this purpose, it retains the status of a Reshus ha'Rabim, unlike a typical wall.

May you continue to attain greatness in Torah and Yir'as Shamayim!

Bi'Verachah,

Yishai Rasowsky