Bechoros Chart #10
Chart for Bechoros Daf 42b
DETERMINING THE GENDER OF A TUMTUM ANIMAL
THE MACHLOKES IN THE BERAISA (42a)
| (A) TANA KAMA |
(B) REBBI SHIMON BEN YEHUDAH |
||
| 1 | IT URINATES LIKE A MALE | Male | Male |
| 2 | IT URINATES LIKE A FEMALE | Safek | Female |
THE MACHLOKES IN THE MISHNAH (41a)
| (A) RAV CHISDA |
(B) REBBI YOCHANAN (1) |
(C) REBBI ILA'I AND REISH LAKISH (2) |
||
| 1 | HOW DOES THE TUMTUM OF THE MISHNAH URINATE? | Like a female | Like a female | Like a male |
| 2 | WHAT DOES THE TANA KAMA RULE? | It is a Safek | It is a Safek | It is a male with no Mum (it is only a Mum mid'Rabanan) |
| 3 | WHAT DO THE CHACHAMIM RULE? | It is a Safek | It is a female | It is a male with no Mum (it is only a Mum mid'Rabanan) |
-------------------------------------------------