Bechoros Chart #8

Chart for Bechoros Daf 35a-b

WHO IS BELIEVED TO TESTIFY THAT A BECHOR ACQUIRED A MUM (1)

(A)
TANA KAMA
(B)
RABAN SHIMON BEN GAMLIEL
(C)
REBBI MEIR
FIRST EXPLANATION
1 A YISRAEL SHEPHERD IN A KOHEN'S HOME Yes Yes (4) Yes
2 A KOHEN SHEPHERD IN A YISRAEL'S HOME No (2) Yes No (3)
3 A KOHEN SHEPHERD IN A KOHEN'S HOME No (2) Yes No (3)
SECOND EXPLANATION
4 A YISRAEL SHEPHERD IN A KOHEN'S HOME No (2) Yes Yes
5 A KOHEN SHEPHERD IN A YISRAEL'S HOME Yes Yes No (3)
6 A KOHEN SHEPHERD IN A KOHEN'S HOME No (2) Yes No (3)
-------------------------------------------------

==========

FOOTNOTES:

==========

(1) According to the two explanations of Rebbi Yochanan and Rebbi Elazar.

(2) Only a shepherd is not believed. Other Kohanim are believed.

(3) Even another Kohen, who is not the animal's shepherd, is not believed.

(4) See Insights (35b).