POINT BY POINT OUTLINE
Prepared by Rabbi P. Feldman of Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Yerushalayim daf@dafyomi.co.il http://www.dafyomi.co.il
1) ONE WITHOUT A WIFE
(a) (R. Elazar): One without a wife is not called Adam -
"Male and female he created them, and he called their
name Adam".
(b) (R. Elazar): One without land is not called Adam - "...
And the land he gave to Bnei Adam".
(c) Version #1 (R. Elazar) Question: How do we explain "I
will make for him a helper against him"?
(d) Answer (R. Elazar): If he merits, she helps him. If not,
she is against him.
(e) Version #2 - Contradiction (R. Elazar): It is written
"k'Negdo" (without a Yud, which allows us to read Nagdaso
(she lashes him)), but we read (k'Negdo, which tolerates
a Yud, i.e. as if it said) "Kenigdo" (she lashes him)!
(f) Resolution: If he merits, she is k'Negdo (an appropriate
companion or helper). If not, she lashes him.
(g) Question (R. Yosi): "I will make for him a helper" - how
does a woman help a man?
(h) Answer (Eliyahu): A man brings (home) wheat and flax, but
he does not chew wheat and wear flax! We see, she
enlightens his eyes and stands him on his feet!
(i) (R. Elazar): "This time, a bone from my bones, flesh from
my flesh" - this teaches that Adam came to every animal,
but his mind was not settled until he came to Chavah.
(Gur Aryeh - he considered each animal as a possible
mate. He did not have relations with them.)
2) FARMING
(a) (R. Elazar): "V'NiVReCHu (will be blessed) through you
all families of the earth" - Hash-m told Avraham 'I have
two BReCHos (graftings) to graft onto you - Rus the
Moabite and Na'amah the Amonite;
1. "All families of the earth" - even families which
dwell in the ground are only blessed because of
Yisrael; (Ya'avetz, Torah Temimah - this alludes to
those who do not dwell in house, e.g. cavemen.)
2. "All nations of the land" - even ships which come
from Galya to Aspamya are only blessed on account of
Yisrael.
(b) (R. Elazar): In the future, all craftsmen will become
farmers - "All oarsmen will descend from their ships and
all ship captains will stand on the ground."
(c) (R. Elazar): There is no lower profession than farming.
It says "They will descend".
1. R. Elazar saw a farmer plowing his field widthwise.
He told him, 'Even if you will also plow lengthwise,
business is more profitable.'
(d) Rav went among the sheaves; the wind was blowing them.
'As much as you can wave, business is more profitable.'
(e) (Rava): One who has 100 Zuz invested in business, can
afford meat and wine every day. One with 100 Zuz of land
will eat salt and fodder. Further, he must sleep on his
land, and comes to quarrels.
(f) (Rav Papa): Plant your own food, rather than buy it. Even
though the price is the same, what you grow will be
blessed;
(g) Sell what is in your house, and do not wax poor;
1. This applies to things like carpets. Do not sell
your cloak, lest you not find another one that fits.
(h) Seal a hole, rather than rebuild the wall. Plaster, but
do not rebuild your house, for anyone that builds is in
danger.
(i) Be quick to buy land, but do not rush to marry a woman.
(j) Marry a woman below your standing; pick a friend above
your level.
(k) (R. Elazar bar Avina): Punishments only come to the world
because of Yisrael - "I cut off nations, made desolate
their towers, and destroyed their markets". "But you
should fear me, learn a lesson from this!"
3) AN EVIL WIFE
(a) R. Chiya (to Rav): Hash-m should save you from something
worse than death.
(b) Question (Rav): Is there such a thing?
(c) Answer (Rav): Yes! "I find a wife harsher than death."
(d) Rav's wife used to pain him. If he would ask her to make
lentils, she would make legumes, and vice-versa. When
Rav's son Chiya grew up, he told his mother the opposite
of what Rav requested.
1. Rav: Your mother has improved (she fulfills my
request)!
2. Chiya: I switched your request.
3. Rav: This is as people say, you will learn from your
children! However, you should not do so - "They
trained their tongues to speak falsely..."
(e) R. Chiya's wife used to pain him. When he would find
something (that she would like), he would wrap it in his
turban and bring it for her.
1. Rav: Why do you do this? She pains you! (Rav wanted
to learn how R. Chiya was able to return good in
place of evil.)
2. R. Chiya: It suffices for us that our wives raise
our children and save us from sin.
63b----------------------------------------63b
(f) Rav Yehudah taught to his son (Rav Yitzchak) "I find a
wife harsher than death".
1. Rav Yitzchak: Who exemplifies this?
2. Rav Yehudah: Your mother does.
(g) Question: Rav Yehudah also taught to his son that a
person finds peace of mind only from his first wife -
"Rejoice in the wife of your youth". He told Rav Yitzchak
that his mother exemplifies this!
(h) Answer: She instigates, but she is easily appeased.
(i) Question: What is the case of an evil wife?
(j) Answer #1 (Abaye): She prepares the food, and a mouth (of
curses).
(k) Answer #2 (Rava): She prepares the food, and turns her
back. (Rashi - she does not eat with him. Tzitz Eliezer -
the Rambam explains that this is a euphemism for
withdrawing at the time of Bi'ah.)
(l) (R. Chama bar Chanina): When a person marries a wife, his
sins MisPaKekin (are plugged up and do not prosecute
against him) - "Motza Ishah Motza Tov v'YiFaK Ratzon
me'Hashem."
(m) In Eretz Yisrael, when a man married they would say to
him 'Motza or Motzei';
1. Motza - "One who found a wife, found good";
2. Motzei - "I find the wife worse than death." (Chasam
Sofer - the message is that even if she will pain
him, he found good, for wives raise children
(enabling him to learn) and save their husbands from
sin.)
(n) (Rava): It is a Mitzvah to divorce an evil wife -
"Divorce the scoffer, expel quarrels and disgrace."
(Chasam Sofer - Rav and R. Chiya did not divorce their
wives because they were righteous in other respects.)
(o) (Rava): The solution for an evil wife with a large
Kesuvah is to marry a Tzarah, like people say, 'another
woman, and not a thorn'.
(p) (Rava): An evil wife is as bad as a day of hail and wind
- "The drip annoys on a day of hail, and a quarrelsome
wife is as bad.
(q) (Rava): See how good is a good wife, and how bad is a
evil wife:
1. If "One who found a wife, found good" discusses a
good wife, the verse praises her;
i. If the verse refers to Torah, this shows that a
good wife is a parable for Torah!
2. If "I find the wife worse than death" discusses an
evil wife, the verse disparages her;
i. If it refers to Gehinom, this shows that an
evil wife is a parable for Gehinom!
(r) (Rav Nachman): "Behold I bring an evil you cannot escape"
refers to an evil wife with a large Kesuvah.
(s) (Rav Chisda): "Hash-m put me in the hands of one from
whom I cannot get up" - this is an evil wife with a large
Kesuvah.
1. In Eretz Yisrael they say that this is one who must
buy (for he does not grow) his food.
4) PUNISHMENTS
(a) (Rav Chanan bar Rava): "Your sons and daughters are given
to another nation" - this is the wife of the father.
(b) Opinion #1 (Rav Chanan bar Rava): "With Naval (a
repulsive) nation I will anger them" refers to an evil
wife with a large Kesuvah;
(c) Opinion #2 (R. Elazar): It refers to Tzedukim - "The
Naval said in his heart, there is not Hash-m".
(d) Opinion #3 (Beraisa): These are the people of Barberiya
and Tartenai, who walk unclothed in the market. There is
nothing more repulsive to Hash-m than this.
(e) Opinion #4 (R. Yochanan): These are Chaverim (Tosfos and
Rashi elsewhere - an ethnic group that corrupted the
Persians).
1. When they told R. Yochanan that Chaverim came to
Bavel, he bent and fell.
2. When they told him that they accept bribes, he
straightened up.
(f) (R. Yochanan): Malchus Bavel made three decrees. They
corresponded to three sins of Yisrael:
1. They decreed not to eat slaughtered meat, because
Yisrael did not give Matanos (the foreleg, jaw and
stomach) of slaughtered animals to Kohanim;
2. They decreed against bathhouses, because Yisrael
were not careful about Tevilah;.
3. They dug up graves, because Yisrael rejoiced on
pagan festivals.
4. (Rabah bar Shmuel) "The hand of Hash-m will be upon
you and your fathers" - this is the digging up of
graves;
i. They dig up the dead due to sins of the living.
(g) Question (Rava): If "They will not be gathered and will
not be buried; they will be as fertilizer on the ground",
how can it be that "Death will be preferred to life"?
(h) Answer (Rabah bar Mari): Death is better for the wicked,
so they will not live and sin in this world and fall in
Gehinom.
(i) (Sefer ben Sira): A good wife is a good gift to her
husband; Good will be given in the lap of one who fears
Hash-m;
1. An evil wife is Tzara'as for her husband. His cure
is to divorce her and heal himself.
2. Happy is the husband of a good wife! His days are
doubled.
3. Hide your eyes from a charming Eshes Ish, lest you
get caught in her trap. Do not befriend her husband,
for many were corrupted and killed by her.
4. Perfume peddlers incite immorality like a spark
ignites a coal. They have many wounds (from irate
husbands). Their houses are full of deception like a
nest is full of fowl.
5. Do not worry about tomorrow, for you do not know
what the day will bring. Perhaps one will not be
alive tomorrow, and he worried over a world which is
not his!
6. Do not allow the multitude into your house. Many
should seek peace with you, but reveal your secrets
to only one out of 1000.
5) THE GREATNESS OF HAVING CHILDREN
(a) (Rav Asi): "Ki Ru'ach mi'Lefanai Ya'atof" - Ben David
will not come until all Neshamos in 'Guf' are completed.
(b) (Beraisa #1 - R. Eliezer): If one does not engage in
procreation, it is as if he spills blood. "One who spills
man's blood..." is followed by "V'Atem Peru u'Rvu."
(c) R. Yakov says, it is as if he diminishes the Divine image
- "(Hash-m) made man in Hashem's image" is followed by
"V'Atem Peru..."
(d) Ben Azai says, it is as if he spills blood and diminishes
the Divine image - "V'Atem Peru u'Rvu..." (follows both
of the above verses).
1. Rabanan, to Ben Azai: Some expound and fulfill
nicely. Some fulfill nicely and do not expound
nicely. You expound nicely and do not fulfill!
2. Ben Azai: What can I do? My soul desires Torah! (I
cannot separate from it to fulfill marital
obligations.) Others can populate the world.
(e) (Beraisa #2 - R. Eliezer): If one does not engage in
procreation, it is as if he spills blood - "One who
spills...; V'Atem Peru u'Rvu...";
(f) R. Elazar ben Azaryah says, it is as if he diminishes the
Divine image;
(g) Ben Azai says (as above, and he had the same dialogue
with Rabanan as above)
Next Daf
Index to Outlines for Maseches Yevamos |