Sunday, Bava Kama 117
V i e w  A l l
(hold mouse over to pause)

 

Dedication


PAST DEDICATION
BAVA KAMA 117 - Dedicated by Dr. David and Ellen Friedman in honor of the Yahrzeit of David's father, Yakov Yosef ben Rav Nosson Neta Z'L Friedman.

 

Summary of the Daf
One Din may be learned out from another Din, but one Knas may not be learned out from another Knas.

At first the Chachamim said that a person who is Mitamei the food of his friend or is Menasech the wine of his friend is obligated to pay and subsequently the Chachamim said also someone who is Medame'a (mixes Terumah with Chulin) is obligated to pay.
Read More

The Beraisa of the father of R. Avin states that at first the Chachamim said that one who is Mitamei or is Medame'a the food of his friend is obligated pay and subsequently the Chachamim said also someone who is Menasech the wine of his friend is obligated to pay.
Read More

R. Avin says someone who throws an arrow on Shabbos four Amos in Reshus ha'Rabim and the arrow rips his friend's clothing in midair is Patur from paying.
Read More

R. Yirmiyah says someone who is Menasech the wine of his friend is Chayav because he is Chayav to pay as soon as he picks it up and the Chiyuv Misah only comes at the time of the actual Nisuch of the wine.
Read More

If a Yisrael was forced by a non-Jew and he pointed out his friend's property to the non-Jew he is Patur, but if he actually took the property in his hands and gave it to the non-Jew he is Chayav.
Read More

Rabah says if someone points out his friend's property to a non-Jew on his own initiative he is Chayav to pay.

If the non-Jew calls out to a person on the other side of a river to hand him a certain property of his friend if he hands it to him he is Chayav.

If there is a dispute between two people and one of them hands over the object of their dispute to the Malchus Rava says that he is put into Cherem until he goes to Din with his friend.

If a Dayan judges a Din incorrectly the Din stands and the Dayan must pay out of his own pocket.

Rav says the Dayan is only Chayav to pay if he took the money with his own hands and gave it to the plaintiff.
Read More

If someone is guarding his friend's silver goblet and thieves break into his house and he gives them the goblet if he is a wealthy person his Chayav, but if not he is Patur.
Read More

If someone was guarding money that was put aside for ransoming captives and thieves broke into his house and he gave them the money he was guarding he is Patur because paying off the thieves is also regarded as ransoming a captive.

If a Rodef breaks utensils while he is running after his friend to kill him he is Patur whether he broke utensils that belong to the person he is pursuing or to someone else.

If the person who is being pursued breaks the utensils of the Rodef he is Patur because the property of the Rodef is not more valuable than his life; since he is allowed to kill the Rodef he may also damage his property.

If the person who is bring pursued breaks the utensils of others in the process of running away he Chayav because he is saving himself with the property of his friend.

If a person breaks utensils while he is pursuing a Rodef he is Patur whether he broke utensils that belong to the Rodef of to other people because if he was Chayav he will not want to purse a Rodef.

If a person steals a field and it is flooded by a river according to R. Eliezer he must give the owner a replacement field, while the Chachamim hold he may return the field as it is.

R. Eliezer holds that only Shtaros are excluded from the Dinim of Shevu'ah and Hashavas ha'Gezeilah, while the Rabanan hold that Karka and servants are also excluded.

If a person steals a field and there is a cow in the field and it is flooded by a river and the cow dies according to R. Eliezer he must pay the owner for the cow, while the Chachamim hold he is Patur.
Read More

 

Brief Insight
SEVEN ROWS BACK

Rav instructed R. Kahana after he killed a Moser that he shall run away to Eretz Yisrael and he shall go learn for R. Yochanan and he shall accept upon himself not to ask questions for seven years. Why did Rav instruct R. Kahana not ask any questions? The answer can't be that it was Teshuvah for killing the Moser because Rav told him that it was the right thing to do. The Maharsha explains that it is a punishment for killing the person without asking his Rebbe first, it was tantamount to making a Halachah decision in front of his Rebbe. The humiliation of refraining from asking any question for seven years was to be atonement for his sin. However, after he was placed seven rows back among the lesser of the students it was sufficient humiliation and it replaced the humiliation of not asking friend seven years and his son was atoned.

 

Quick Halachah
PAYMENT OF A MOSER

Someone who is Moser the money of his friend to a thief whether he was Moser it to a Jewish or a non-Jewish thief he is Chayav to pay from the best of his property everything that the thief took. Even though the Moser didn't pick it up and give it to the thief and only directed him to it he is Chayav. If he dies the money is collected from the inheritors of he Moser just like other damages. (Shulchan Aruch CM 338:2)

 

Chakirah
If a Yisrael was forced by a non-Jew and he pointed out his friend's property to the non-Jew he is Patur but if he actually took the property in his hands and gave it to the non-Jew he is Chayav. Why is he Chayav if he took the property in his hands? It is an Ones!
Author's Suggestion
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

Dafyomi Advancement Forum       

The Internet Center for the Study of Talmud
brought to you by Kollel Iyun Hadaf
Rosh Kollel: Rav Mordecai Kornfeld



Please Donate Now
Donate to
Kollel Iyun Hadaf
Send me a Calendar
Order your
FREE Dafyomi calendar!



members Ask the Kollel

Yerushalmi/Bavli Calendar
THE CURRENT SEDER NEZIKIN HAS BEEN DEDICATED לע"נ
REBBETZIN HENIE MEISELS AND HER MOTHER REBBETZIN HINDA TRESS OB"M

MASECHES BAVA KAMA
Sunday's Daf is קיז (117)



PAST DEDICATION
BAVA KAMA 117 - Dedicated by Dr. David and Ellen Friedman in honor of the Yahrzeit of David's father, Yakov Yosef ben Rav Nosson Neta Z'L Friedman.


"YOMI" STUDY LINKS

         

REFERENCE LIBRARY

       
chavrusa

אתר שומר שבת
The Dafyomi Advancement Forum is grateful to the following
for grants towards the programming and design for this page:

Zachary Prensky, Asher Schoor, Shmuel Kovacs


Sponsorships & donations  •  Readers' feedback
Mailing lists  •  Archives  •  Ask the Kollel
Dafyomi weblinks  •  Calendar
חומר לימוד בעברית

Israel: P.O.B. 43087, Jerusalem 91430, • US: 140-32 69 Ave., Flushing, NY 11367
Tel. (Israel): (02) 651-5004 • Fax (Israel): (02) 591-6024 • Voicemail/Fax (USA): 1 646 820-3315 • daf@dafyomi.co.il

Subscribe
to email