More Discussions for this daf
1. Tosfos "V'Ein Davar Achar Kortah" 2. Ein Kesef Superfluous? 3. b'Ne'ure'ha Beis Aviha
4. bi'Ne'ureha Beis Aviha 5. Rashi DH Mipnei she'Darko 6. Amah Ivriyah Ailonis
7. Father marrying off his daughter 8. Rashi DH d'Avahu 9. Excluding Chupah
10. d'Ika Plugta 11. Insights to the Daf - Chupah Koneh 12. Chalitzah of a Married Woman
13. "Al Kol Mayim" 14. Kinyan Chalipin 15. למעוטי חופה
16. דאיכא פלוגתא
DAF DISCUSSIONS - KIDUSHIN 3

Hersch Isler asked:

In the perush of "M. Kornfeld" it's writed:

"Since it is possible that the daughter is the one who accepts the Kesef or Shtar, the Gemara cannot be saying that the father has the ability to give his daughter to a Menuval in exchange for being Mekadesh her with Kidushei Kesef or Shtar, because even though the father agrees to the Kidushin, if his daughter refuses to accept (and make a Kinyan on) the Kesef or Shtar the Kidushin cannot take effect." - the question is: where we know that's necessary to the daughter accept ? If the father accept the money then isn't the kidushin completed ? That's right that to swerve the kushia: "v'Hi ha'Nosenes" (see Tosfos DH v'Chi Teima and Tosfos Kesuvos 40 DB d'Iy) it's a good answer but where do we know that she needs to agree ?

Hersch Isler, S. Paulo, Brazil

The Kollel replies:

I think that is a good question, as the Ritva (5a, DH "Kesef Nami") understands that it is a given that a person can be Mekadesh his daughter who is a Na'arah Ba'al Korchah, using Kesef.

On the other hand, the question is on Rashi, and Rabbi Kornfeld's Chidush could answer the Ritva's question.

Yaakov Montrose