1)

PEOPLE WHO MAY RECEIVE DEMAI (Yerushalmi Perek 3 Halachah 1 Daf 11a)

îùðä îàëéìéï àú äòðééí ãîàé åàú äàëñðéà ãîàé

(a)

(Mishnah): One may feed Demai to the poor and to passing guests. (This often refers to the king's soldiers who travel around and must be supported by the local populace.)

ø"â äéä îàëéì àú äôåòìéí ãîàé

(b)

Rabban Gamliel would feed Demai to his workers (as they were poor).

âáàé öã÷ä [ãó ëã òîåã à (òåæ åäãø)] á"ù àåîøéí ðåúðéï àú äîòåùø ìùàéðå îòùø åàú ùàéðå îòåùø ìîòùø ðîöàå ëì àãí àåëìéï îúå÷ï

(c)

Charity collectors - Beis Shammai say - give the tithed produce to those that do not tithe; and untithed produce to those that tithe; so that everyone ultimately eats tithed produce.

åçëîéí àåîøéí [ãó éà òîåã á] âåáéï ñúí åîçì÷éï ñúí åäøåöä ìú÷ï éú÷ï:

(d)

(Chachamim): We collect and distribute to all and whoever wants to tithe, let him tithe.

âîøà àîø øáé éåðä îúðé' áòðéé çáøéí åáàëñðéà ëøáé éäåùò

(e)

(R. Yona): When the Mishnah allowed feeding Demai to the poor, it referred to poor Chaverim. The case of the king's soldiers that the Mishnah permitted was as in the teaching of R. Yehoshua...

úðé îòùä áøáé éäåùò ùäìê àçø øáï éåçðï áï æëàé ìáøåø çéì åäéå àåúï áðé òééøåú îáéàéï ìäï ôéøåú

1.

Baraisa: Once, R. Yehoshua followed R. Yochanan ben Zakkai to Berur Chayil and the local townspeople brought them fruits from the field.

àîø ìäï øáé éäåùò àí ìðå ëàï çéáéé' àðå ìòùø åàí ìàå àéï çééáéï ìòùø

2.

(R. Yehoshua to the people): Once we have already slept here, we are obligated to tithe; before that, we are exempt.

øáé éåñé àîø áòðéé òí äàøõ äéà îúðéúà àí àîø àú áòðéé çáøéí ðîöàú ðåòì ãìú áôðé òí äàøõ

(f)

(R. Yosi): (Disagreeing with R. Yona) The Mishnah is referring to poor Amei HaAretz. If you would say that it refers to poor Chaverim, you have closed the door in front of the Amei HaAretz.

îä î÷ééí ø' éåñé ìàëñðéà

(g)

Question: How does R. Yosi explain the case of the passing guests?

ëäãà ãúðé äâøéí òîëí ìøáåú àú äàëñðéà

(h)

Answer: Like the Baraisa - the pasuk states (Vayikra 25:6), "(And [the produce of] the Shabbos of the land {Shemittah) shall be yours to eat for you, for your male and female slaves, and for your hired worker and resident) who live with you" - this includes the passing guest (meaning that you may feed those workers Shemittah produce, even though it is as if you are paying off a debt with the produce).

øáé ìòæø àåîø æå àëñðéà ùì òëå"í

(i)

(R. Elazar): This refers to gentile passing guests.

úðé öøéê ìäåãéò

(j)

Baraisa: You must inform (the poor man that you are giving him Demai).

òì ãòúéä ãøáé éåðä ãå àîø áòðéé çáøéí äéà îúðéúà ðéçà òì ãòúéä ãøáé éåñé ãå àîø áòðéé òí äàøõ äéà îúðéúà àôé' îåãéòå îäå îåòéì

(k)

Question: According to R. Yona who said that the Mishnah refers to poor Chaverim, it is fine; but according to R. Yosi who said that they are poor Amei HaAretz, even if you inform them, what would it help?

îôðé à' (ùàéðå)[ùäåà] îú÷ï

(l)

Answer: Perhaps there will be someone who will tithe.

[ãó ëã òîåã á (òåæ åäãø)] àîø øáé îðà äãà àîøä àéìéï ãéäáåï ááéúéï àñåø ìéúï îãîé ùáéòéú ùàéðå àìà ëôåøò çåáå îãîé ùáéòéú

(m)

(R. Mana): (Earlier R. Yehoshua only obligated those that slept the night to separate Demai) This teaches that those travelling poor who are hosted in different houses in the town, may not be given food from Sheviis money, as it is like paying a debt with Sheviis money.

ëäãà ãúðé àçã ùáéòéú åàçã îòùø ùðé àéï ðôøòéï îäï îìåä åçåá åàéï òåùéï îäï ùåùáéðåú åàéï îùìîéï îäï úùìåîé' åàéï ôåñ÷éï îäï öã÷ä ìòðééí ááéú äëðñú àáì îùìîéï îäí ãáø ùì âîéìåú çñã åöøéê ìäåãéò

(n)

Support (Baraisa): With Sheviis or Maaser Sheni money, a person may not pay off a debt, nor provide a meal of mere friendship, nor pay back (a favor), nor pledge from them charity in the Shul; but one may use them to pay for any matter of kindness, and he must inform them that the produce is from Sheviis or Maaser Sheni.