Pesachim Chart #12
Chart for Pesachim Daf 82b-83a
WHEN ARE DIFFERENT TYPES OF KORBANOS PESULOS BURNED?
(A) BURNED IMMEDIATELY |
(B) REQUIRES "IBUR TZURAH" |
||
1 | TANA D'VEI RABAH BAR AVUHA |
--- | Pesul in Dam (1) Ba'alim or Basar (2) |
2 | RABANAN OF OUR MISHNAH |
Pesul in Basar | Pesul in Dam or Ba'alim |
3 | REBBI YOSI HA'GLILI (ACCORDING TO REBBI YOCHANAN) (3) |
Pesul in Basar or Dam |
Pesul in Ba'alim |
4 | REBBI YOCHANAN BEN BEROKAH (ACCORDING TO REBBI YOCHANAN) (4), AND REBBI YOSI HA'GLILI (ACCORDING TO RABAH), AND REBBI NECHEMYAH |
Pesul in Basar, Dam, or Ba'alim |
--- |
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) That is, the blood became Pasul and the Zerikah cannot be done with it, and as a result the Korban itself becomes Pasul since Zerikah was not performed.
(2) This applies to the Korban Pesach, which may be slaughtered only for those who are fit to eat from it, and to the Korban of a Nazir, since if he becomes Tamei his days Nezirus are annulled and he cannot bring the Korbanos of a Nazir Tahor.
(3) According to Rabah, Rebbi Yosi ha'Glili's opinion is identical to that of Rebbi Yochanan ben Berokah.
(4) According to Rav Yosef who argues with Rebbi Yochanan, Rebbi Yochanan ben Berokah agrees to the Chachamim of our Mishnah and is not adding anything to what they say except that if the Ba'alim become Tamei before Zerikah, it is considered as if the Korban has a Pesul ha'Guf. Since the Ba'alim must bring the Pesach Sheni, it is considered as if the Korban Pesach had its Zerikah performed without Ba'alim, which he equates to a Pesul ha'Guf in the Korban itself (for the primary purpose of the Korban Pesach is to be eaten).