More Parasha-Pages
Rabbi Mordecai Kornfeld's
Weekly
Parasha-Page

Ask a
Question

Dedicated by Yitz and Esther Brown in honor of Mr. and Mrs. A. Brown and Mr. and Mrs. L. Weinstock of Brooklyn, NY. May they continue to see much Nachas from their combined families.

PARASHAT PEKUDEI 5757

THE BREASTPLATE AND THE APRON

"And the Choshen (the High-Priest's breastplate) may not be untied from the Ephod (apron, one of the eight high-priestly garments), as Hashem commanded Moshe"
(Shmot 39:21)
One of the reasons for this Mitzvah is that Hashem wanted ... everything [in the Temple] to be perfect and set in its proper place... that their beauty should be unmarred. The point of this particular command is to ensure that the Choshen would not move and sway but rather would stand firmly in its place. This is how I shall understand this Mitzvah until I hear a better explanation.
(Sefer Hachinuch, Mitzvah #100 -- Moreh Nevuchim [3:45] suggests a different understanding of the Mitzvah which the Chinuch apparently found to be less appealing than his own)
The author of the Chinuch finds the reason that he gives for the command to bind the Choshen to the Ephod somewhat lacking, leaving us room to offer our own suggestions as to the meaning of this Mitzvah.

II

The Gemara equates a crooked judge to a proponent of idolatry:

One who appoints a justice who is not worthy [i.e., who is not well versed in Jewish law], is compared to one who plants an Asheirah (a tree of idol-worship).
(Sanhedrin 7b)
A judge who judges untruthfully causes the Divine Presence to be removed from Israel.
(ibid.)
This concept is quite understandable. It is the responsibility of a king to provide his nation with justice: "A king, through justice, will preserve the land" (Mishlei 29:4). Both King David (Shmuel II 8:15) and King Solomon (Kings I 3:16) are depicted in Scriptures as judges of the people.

Hashem, as King of the entire world, holds the responsibility to administer justice in His world. The Jewish judges are His emissaries, meting out justice based on the guidelines He set forth for them in His Torah. Judges are referred to as "Elokim" (Shmot 21:6 etc.) for, as Ibn Ezra explains, they are His emissaries, bringing about justice in the world, and an emissary can be referred to by the name of the one whom he is representing (see Sanhedrin 38b, "his name is like that of his master"- see also Ramban Shmot 21:6). When they announce a decision, it is as if they are declaring, "Hashem says to do such and such in this situation."

When proper justice, as dictated by the Torah, is practiced, it brings peace to the world. It is evident to all that the world has a caring king, who is "preserving it with justice." For this reason, "He who judges in a true and proper manner, causes the Divine Presence to rest among Israel" (Sanhedrin 7a). Inversely, when a judge misrepresents his master and dispatcher, he causes a desecration of the Holy Name. People are led to believe that Hashem cannot administer true justice in the world. This is what the verse means by saying, "Do not give anyone preferential treatment when judging...do not fear any person while judging, because Justice is the responsibility of Hashem" (Devorim 1:17). A judge is administering the responsibility of the Creator, therefore injustice that he causes will ultimately be attributed to Him. Thus, appointing an unjust judge can be compared to planting an Asheirah, for such a judge causes people to respect ideals other than Hashem's divine edicts, and to trust in them as coming from Hashem. This is why Rashi says (Shmot 21:1), "One who brings a quarrel before non-Jewish courts profanes the Holy name and shows honor for idol worshippers, praising their idols... as if to bear witness to the superiority of their Gods."

III

This may be the message of the command to permanently bind the Choshen to the Ephod. The Gemara in Zevachim (88b) tells us, "Just as the sacrifices brought atonement, so did the garments that the priests wore.... The Choshen atones for injustice... and the Ephod atones for idol- worship." The Choshen breastplate represents the justice of Hashem's true word. When in doubt as to the proper course of action, the king would consult the Choshen for divine advice. A beautifully woven apron often adorned idols, and the Ephod of the Jewish High Priest demonstrated that we reserve such majesty for the priests of Hashem alone.

The command that the Choshen may not be untied from the Ephod reminds our judges that the justice which they are appointed to administer is representative of Hashem's Own word. Inevitably, if they administer Hashem's laws faithfully they will bring the world to respect Him as Creator of the universe. On the other hand, if they misrepresent His laws they are misrepresenting Hashem, which is tantamount to idol worship!

Perhaps the permanence of the bond is also hinting that even when he is not in court, if a judge acts in an improper manner he will cause disrespect for his Creator. His actions will be viewed as a reflection of Hashem's will.

(I later found that Yalkut Yitzchak, Mitzvah #100, cites in brief a similar explanation from Ta'amai Hamitzvot [of the Rikanati].)


Visit the
Dafyomi Advancement Forum

3