POINT BY POINT OUTLINE
Prepared by Rabbi Yisrael Shaw of Kollel Iyun Hadaf daf@dafyomi.co.il http://www.dafyomi.co.il
1) THE EXTENT OF THE DETAILS IN THE TORAH OF OTHER CATEGORIES OF "HALACHAH"
(a) (Beraisa): The laws of Ohalos have very few verses but
many detailed laws.
(b) The laws of Nega'im have many verses but few detailed
laws.
(c) Question: What difference does it make?
(d) Answer: When one has a doubt, he should know where to
look to find the answer (for a doubt in Hilchos Ohalos,
he should look in the Mishnah, and for a doubt in Hilchos
Nega'im, he should look in the Torah).
2) THE LAWS OF "DINIM" (LEGAL JUDGMENTS) HAVE WHAT TO RELY UPON
(a) Question: But they are written explicitly in the Torah!?
(b) Answer: The Mishnah is referring to the teaching of Rebbi
(which is not explicit in the Torah).
1. Rebbi taught that the verse, "If there is a fatal
injury, then he must pay a life for a life," (Shemos
21:23) means that one must pay a monetary penalty
(and not literally his life), as is derived from a
Gezeirah Shavah.
3) THE LAWS OF "AVODOS" (TEMPLE SERVICE) HAVE WHAT TO RELY UPON
(a) Question: But they are written explicitly in the Torah!?
(b) Answer: The Mishnah is referring to the Avodah of
Holachas ha'Dam (which is not explicit in the Torah) and
is teaching that Holachas ha'Dam has the status of a
full-fledged Avodah.
1. This is derived from the verses which teach that
Holachas ha'Dam is included in the Avodah of Kabalas
ha'Dam.
4) THE LAWS OF "TAHAROS" (RITUAL PURIFICATION) HAVE WHAT TO RELY UPON
(a) Question: But they are written explicitly in the Torah!?
(b) Answer: The Mishnah is referring to the Shi'ur of a
Mikvah (which is not explicit in the Torah).
1. A Mikvah must hold at least 40 Se'ah of water, as
the Chachamim derived from the verses.
5) THE LAWS OF "TUM'OS" (RITUAL IMPURIFICATION) HAVE WHAT TO RELY UPON
(a) Question: But they are written explicitly in the Torah!?
(b) Answer: The Mishnah is referring to the Tum'ah caused by
a small piece (the size of a barley seed) of a Sheretz
(which is not explicit in the Torah).
1. A part of a Sheretz will be Metamei if it is the
size of the smallest complete Sheretz, as is derived
from the verses.
2. (Chachamim): This is the size of a barley seed,
since a Chomet's full size is a barley seed when it
is born.
3. (R. Yosi b'R. Yehudah): This is the size of the tail
of a Halta'ah (which, when dismembered, still moves
around, and is thus considered a complete Sheretz).
6) THE LAWS OF "ARAYOS" (IMMORAL RELATIONS) HAVE WHAT TO RELY UPON
(a) Question: But they are written explicitly in the Torah!?
11b----------------------------------------11b
(b) Answer: The Mishnah is referring to the prohibition of
having relations with the daughter of the woman one raped
(which is not explicit in the Torah).
1. This prohibition (and its punishment of Sereifah)
are derived from a Gezeirah Shavah.
7) THESE ARE THE BODY (ESSENTIAL PART) OF THE TORAH
(a) Question: Only "these" laws, but not all of the others!?
(b) Answer: Rather, the Mishnah should read "These and these
are the body of the Torah" (meaning all laws,
regardless of whether they are explicit or are derived,
are equal and constitute the body of the Torah).
*****PEREK EIN DORSHIN*****
8) "MISHNAH": "EIN DORSHIN"
(a) Arayos may not be expounded with three people.
(b) Ma'aseh Bereishis may not be expounded with two people.
(c) Ma'aseh Merkavah may not be expounded with one person.
1. It may be expounded with one person if he is a
Chacham and he understands things by himself.
(d) Anyone who looks into one of four things is better off
having not been created:
1. What is above the world,
2. What is below the world,
3. What is before the world,
4. What is behind (after) the world.
(e) Anyone who does not have compassion for the honor of his
Creator is better off having not been created.
9) TO WHOM MAY ONE TEACH THE SECRETS OF THE TORAH
(a) Question: The Mishnah first says that Ma'aseh Merkavah
may not be expounded by one person, which implies that he
is already a Chacham if he is learning by himself, and
even so he may not expound Ma'aseh Merkavah, and then it
says that one person may expound it if he is a Chacham?!
(b) Answer: The Mishnah means that Arayos may not be
expounded to three people, Ma'aseh Bereishis to two
people, and Ma'aseh Merkavah to one person, unless that
person is a Chacham and understands things by himself.
(c) What is the reason Arayos may not be taught to three
people?
1. It is not because of any implication in the verses.
2. Rather, it is logical; when the secrets of the
Halachos of Arayos are taught to only two people,
one of the students engages in discussion with the
Rebbi, and the other one listens.
3. But when taught to three people, one engages in
discussion with the Rebbi, and the other two discuss
it amoung themselves, not hearing what the Rebbi
says, and they might come to permit an Isur of
Arayos.
(d) This reasoning applies only to Arayos, but to other
topics in the Torah.
1. This is because people lust for Arayos.
2. And they lust for Arayos both when the opportunity
presents itself and when it does not (whereas a
person only lusts for thievery when the opportunity
presents itself).
(e) What is the reason Ma'aseh Bereishis may not be taught to
two people?
1. The verse says, "For ask now regarding the early
days that preceded you" (Devarim 4:32), in the
singular form.
2. One may not ask about what was before the world was
created, for the verse continues, "... from the day
that Hash-m created man on the earth."
3. One may inquiure, however, about the first six days
of Creation (before man was created), for the verse
says, "... regarding the early days that preceded
you."
4. One may not ask about what is above the world, below
the world, before the world, or after the world, for
the verse says, "... from one end of the heaven to
the other end of the heaven."
Next Daf
Index to Outlines for Maseches Chagigah |